[time 806] Re: [time 805] Re: [time 804] Re: [time 803] Re: [time 801] Re: [time 799] Stillabout construction of U

Hitoshi Kitada (hitoshi@kitada.com)
Sat, 25 Sep 1999 20:57:05 +0900

Dear Matti,

Matti Pitkanen <matpitka@pcu.helsinki.fi> wrote:

Subject: [time 805] Re: [time 804] Re: [time 803] Re: [time 801] Re: [time
799] Stillabout construction of U

> You might be right in that one can formally introduce
> time from S-matrix. Indeed the replacement p_+--> id/dt in
> mass squared operator p_kp^k= 2p_+p_--p_T^2
> seems to lead to Schrodinger equation if my earlier arguments
> are correct.
> This replacement is however not needed and is completely ad hoc since
> the action of p_+ is in any case well defined.

By "action of p_+" what do you mean? Does it make your "quantum jump" occur?

> Unless one interprets
> the time coordinate conjugate to p_+ as one configuration space
> coordinate associated with space of 3-surfaces at light cone boundary
> delta M^4_+xCP_2.

I do not understand this sentence.


> > > In TGD approach one has
> > >
> > > L_0(tot) Psi=0 rather than HPsi = EPsi! No energy, no time!!
> > >
> > > By the way, this condition is analogous to your condition
> > > that entire universe has vanishing energy
> > >
> > > HPsi=0
> > >
> > > Thus there is something common between our approaches!
> >
> > Then you agree with that there is no time for the total universe?
> >
> I agree in the sense that there is no need to assign time to U: just
> S-matrix describes quantum evolution associated with each quantum jump.

If the total state \Psi is an eigenstate of the total Hamiltonian L_0(tot) of
yours, how the "quantum jump" occur? See

L_0(tot) \Psi = 0,

and \Psi is the total state. There is nothing happen. Scattering operator S
of the universe becomes I, the identity operator. No scattering occur. How
quantum jump can exist?

> This might be even impossible.
> But there is geometric time associated with imbedding
> space and spacetime surfaces: in this respect TGD differs from
> GRT where also TGD formalism would lead to a loss of geometric time.

Then you agree that also geometric time does not exist?

> And there is the subjective time associated with
> quantum jump sequence (nothing geometrical) and psychological time is kind
> of hybrid of subjective and geometric time.

In view of the two observation above, there is no psychological time of the
total universe?

Best wishes,

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Sat Oct 16 1999 - 00:36:41 JST